M. Megan Hunter UK & Europe · Remote
Work with me Testimonials Client results About Blog Book an intro call
Consumer Duty

Consumer Duty fair value assessments.

Most firms can show me a fair value assessment. There's usually some competitor benchmarking, some margin analysis, maybe a RAG rating. All useful. What's much harder to show is whether the product does what customers need it to do, based on how they use it.

That gap is the bit I help with. This page is my plain-English guide to the price and value outcome: what the rules say, what the FCA has said about how firms do it, and where I'd look first. It isn't legal advice, and your compliance team owns the interpretation.

What fair value means under the Consumer Duty

Price and value is one of the four Consumer Duty outcomes. The rules are in PRIN 2A.4. Value is the relationship between what a customer pays and the benefits they can reasonably expect to get. A product gives fair value when the price is reasonable compared with those benefits.

A manufacturer has to make sure its products give fair value to customers in the target market. It has to carry out a value assessment before a product, or a significant change to one, is marketed or distributed. Then it has to review that assessment regularly. A distributor can't distribute a product unless its own arrangements are consistent with the product giving fair value.

The rules came into force on 31 July 2023 for products open to sale or renewal, and on 31 July 2024 for closed products. That timetable is in PS22/9.

What a value assessment has to include

PRIN 2A.4 sets a minimum. The assessment has to consider:

  • The nature of the product. The benefits it gives, or that customers can reasonably expect, and its quality.
  • Its limitations. For example, what an insurance policy doesn't cover.
  • The expected total price. What the customer pays upfront, regular charges over the life of the product, contingent charges such as arrears or transfer fees, and any non-financial costs.
  • Vulnerability. Any characteristics of vulnerability in the target market, and how they affect the chance of a customer not getting fair value.

Firms can also look at their own costs, market rates for comparable products, costs and benefits already built up on existing or closed products, and whether anything similar or better is priced much lower. Benefits can be non-financial, like extra help using the product. Costs can be non-financial too, like handing over personal data.

One line in the rules I'd underline. A firm can't rely on customers deciding for themselves whether something is fair value instead of doing its own assessment.

Fair value is about more than price

The FCA put it plainly in Enforcement Watch: "A product or service that doesn't meet any of the customer's needs, causes foreseeable harm, or frustrates their objectives, is unlikely to offer fair value whatever the price."

In the same edition the FCA said it had 11 investigations open into potential Consumer Duty breaches. I wrote about what that means in fair value was never just about price.

Look at groups, not the average

The guidance in PRIN 2A.4 asks manufacturers to think about two things. Are customers with characteristics of vulnerability less likely to get fair value? And does each group in the target market get fair value, including where different groups pay different prices?

This is where averages can hide things. When the FCA reviewed firms' fair value frameworks, it found some relied on average outcomes. It said group averages could disguise outliers or pockets of poor value. It also said firms using market benchmarks should think about value in absolute terms, not only relative ones, because relative comparisons can hide problems that run across a whole market.

The rules don't say everyone has to pay the same price, or that a firm has to make the same profit from every customer. They do say you have to be able to show that each group gets fair value.

What the FCA found when it reviewed fair value frameworks

In 2023 the FCA reviewed 14 firms' fair value frameworks and published what it found. It flagged four areas to work on:

  • collecting and monitoring evidence that products give fair value
  • clear ownership of what happens when a product doesn't
  • looking at how outcomes spread across groups of customers, beyond broad averages
  • presenting assessments so decision-makers can challenge them, including being clear about the limits of the evidence

Some of the weaker frameworks leaned on unevidenced claims that the firm's business model or ethos was fair value by nature. Some didn't mention profit margins at all. Some ignored non-financial costs, like the time and effort it takes to change or cancel a product. Some used points or RAG ratings without enough challenge behind them.

The review was written before the Duty came in. The points still make a good checklist.

Closed books and legacy products

The fair value rules apply to closed products too. For a closed product, the target market means the customers who hold it. The assessment looks forward. Unless another rule says otherwise, you don't have to work out whether a closed or existing product gave fair value before the rules came in, and you can take into account the benefits and costs from before then.

If a product no longer gives fair value, the manufacturer has to act. That means reducing harm to existing customers, putting it right where appropriate, and stopping harm to new customers. For closed products, and existing products held before 31 July 2023, that action doesn't have to mean giving up vested contractual rights, unless the firm has found a breach of the earlier rules.

Closed books are often the awkward ones nobody volunteers for, which is why I'd look at them early.

Pensions: value for money and fair value

If you're a pension provider covered by COBS 19.5, your Independent Governance Committee or governance advisory arrangement already carries out a value for money assessment. PRIN 2A.4 says you have to use that assessment when you do your fair value assessment. If you disagree with it, you have to explain why, and set out how the scheme or pathway investment gives fair value using the COBS 19.5 framework.

I spent 7+ years at Standard Life, a pensions and savings provider, so this is familiar ground for me.

Where I'd start

If I were looking at your fair value assessment tomorrow, this is where I'd start:

  1. Write down what the product is for, in a sentence a customer would recognise.
  2. Look at how customers use it over time, not only what it costs. Claims, cancellations, complaints, and the features people pay for and never use.
  3. Split the results by group, including customers with characteristics of vulnerability, back-book customers and different channels.
  4. Put the non-financial costs on the page: time, hassle and data.
  5. Talk to the customers who never make it into a focus group.
  6. Make the board paper honest about what the evidence can't tell you.
  7. Give every action a named owner and a date.

It's slower than updating a spreadsheet. It's also the version that would stand up if someone outside the firm asked you to prove it.

How I help with fair value

I come at fair value from customer experience and proposition, not law. I'm not a law firm and I'm not a compliance monitor. I work alongside your compliance team on:

  • an external challenge of your fair value assessments before they go to the board
  • the customer evidence behind them, including how different groups get on with the product
  • closed book and legacy product reviews
  • redesigning a product or proposition when the evidence says it isn't delivering

The wider picture is on my Consumer Duty page. If you want a bounded start, the 2-4 week diagnostic can include a Consumer Duty gap analysis. If the fix is the product itself, see proposition and go-to-market for regulated products.

Book an intro call

Common questions

What is a fair value assessment under the Consumer Duty?

It's the assessment a manufacturer has to carry out to check that a product gives fair value to customers in its target market. Under PRIN 2A.4, value is the relationship between what the customer pays and the benefits they can reasonably expect. A product gives fair value when the price is reasonable compared with those benefits.

What does a Consumer Duty value assessment have to include?

At a minimum: the nature of the product, including its benefits and quality; any limitations; the expected total price, including regular, contingent and non-financial costs; and any characteristics of vulnerability in the target market and how they affect the chance of a customer not getting fair value. Firms can also consider their own costs, market rates and comparable products.

How often should we review a fair value assessment?

PRIN 2A.4 says a manufacturer must review its value assessment regularly, at a frequency that suits the nature and duration of the product. There also has to be an assessment before a product, or a significant change to it, is marketed or distributed. In its 2023 review, the FCA saw frameworks that linked review frequency to how long customers keep a product or how often it renews.

Does fair value mean we have to charge every customer the same?

No. The FCA has said the price and value rules don't require firms to charge all customers the same amount, or to make the same profit from every customer. You do need to be able to show that each group of customers in the target market gets fair value, including where groups pay different prices.

Is benchmarking against competitors enough to show fair value?

Not on its own. Market rates are one factor a firm may consider. The FCA has said relative comparisons can hide fair value problems that run across a whole market, and that firms should think about value in absolute terms too. It has also said a product that doesn't meet customers' needs is unlikely to give fair value whatever the price.

Do closed products need a fair value assessment?

Yes. The Consumer Duty applied to closed products from 31 July 2024. For a closed product, the target market is the customers who hold it, and the assessment looks forward. If a closed product no longer gives fair value, the firm has to take appropriate action.

How does a pensions value for money assessment fit with fair value?

If your firm is covered by COBS 19.5, PRIN 2A.4 says you must use the value for money assessment carried out by your Independent Governance Committee or governance advisory arrangement in your fair value assessment. If you disagree with it, you have to explain why and show how the scheme or pathway investment gives fair value using the COBS 19.5 framework.

Can you review our fair value assessments?

Yes. I give fair value assessments an external challenge from the customer side: whether the evidence shows the product works for the people who hold it, including different groups and customers in vulnerable circumstances. I'm not a law firm or a compliance monitor, so your compliance team stays the owner of the regulatory interpretation.

Related reading

  • Consumer Duty consultant
  • The FCA has 11 open Consumer Duty investigations. Fair value was never just about price
  • Vulnerable customers and the Consumer Duty
  • FCA targeted support, explained

Sources

  1. FCA Handbook, PRIN 2A.4 Consumer Duty: retail customer outcome on price and value. Viewed 16 November 2026.
  2. FCA, PS22/9: A new Consumer Duty. Published 27 July 2022.
  3. FCA, Consumer Duty: findings from our review of fair value frameworks. First published 10 May 2023.
  4. FCA, Enforcement Watch 2.
  5. FCA Handbook, COBS 19.5 Independent Governance Committees.
  6. FCA, FG22/5: Final non-Handbook Guidance for firms on the Consumer Duty.
Get in touch

Let's work together.

Book an intro call hello@megan-hunter.com
M. Megan Hunter

Customer experience, strategy and operations leader

Explore
Services Fractional and interim Client results Testimonials About Blog FAQs Links
Topics
Consumer Duty Vulnerable customers Financial inclusion Digital inclusion Social sustainability AI and customer service Fair value assessments FCA targeted support AI and vulnerable customers
Elsewhere
LinkedIn The Making It Matter Podcast Founder, Nadi Megan's Substack
Contact
hello@megan-hunter.com Book a call
© 2026 Megan Hunter. All rights reserved.
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy